Pizza By Yandys

Carmen Hall-Buchanon

So good we had them twice! Seriously, we loved Pizza by Yandys so much that we ordered it two days in a row when we first tried it! The first day we went on a Friday. Fortunately, the place wasn't too busy, so we were able to place our order right away. It took about 15-20 minutes for our pizza to be made since they prepare everything to order. There are tables and chairs inside, so we were able to have a seat while we waited. This pizza place is nestled inside a Mexican store, with a Mexican restaurant on one side and the pizza shop on the other. During our first visit, we tried a half white pizza with sausage and half honey hot char pepperoni pizza. Both pizzas were delicious, but we slightly favored the honey hot more. The pizza is reminiscent of New York-style: it has a thin, foldable crust, large slices, and fair prices. The customer service was pleasant and efficient, and our pizza arrived hot and fresh. My husband enjoyed it so much that he wanted to get a box of the honey hot pizza for dinner the next day. We still enjoyed it, as we did the day before. If you're looking to try a new pizza place in Georgia, be sure to check them out! You won't regret it!

Scot Gilmore

I’ve been here twice in about a month. After doing some reading I was eager to try this place. Love the atmosphere of finding a small pizza joint within a Hispanic grocery store. First trip- Meat lovers NY style & pepperoni hot char Detroit style. Second trip was a veggie NY and pepperoni hot char due to being out of Detroit. Hard to find good Detroit style and NY style in this city…I cannot stress enough how much this team nailed it for BOTH. NY stole the show for me, but I still loved the Detroit. This was only because a friend had recently baked some Detroit style for me. I’m ruined. As a pizza guy, It’s hard to eat pizza anywhere else now…even my own. I’ll always be willing to make the trip from Cumming. I should have tried to buy some dough to take home. Great place. Worth the hype. Forever a customer.

Jen Lyles

I tell you what...THIS PIZZA is WORTH THE HYPE! BEST CRUST in Atlanta! I just kept "looking at it". It was SO GOOD! The most random place in the world. SOOO GOOD! Its in the Mexican Grocery store. The freshness is what you have been LOOKING FOR!

Pascal

This pizzeria is tucked inside a Mexican supermarket and easy to miss, but definitely worth seeking out. I ordered the margherita and added pepperoni to half - the crust had great char and structure, slightly crisp on the outside while staying soft inside. The sauce had a nice subtle sweetness, and one of the cheeses (likely Parmesan) added a sharper bite that balanced everything well. Ordering through the app was straightforward, the quoted time of about 25 minutes was accurate, and pickup was quick with almost no wait. Very solid pizza overall and worth a stop if you’re nearby.

Joe Farrell

Great pizza ! Most authentic NY/NJ pizza i had in Atlanta. Highly recommend for up north transplants missing home or anyone who likes real NY Style pizza. Will definitely be back for more ! Keep up the GREAT work ! Medium Meat Lovers pictured.