Pizza By Yandys

Erik Gilleo

Eater Atlanta published The Best Pizza Place in Atlanta May Be Hidden Inside a Mexican Grocery Store. We read the writeup on Pizza by Yandys, reviewed the menu, and investigated in-person at lunch. We ordered a slice of Detroit style cheese, a meat lovers stromboli, and two Diet Cokes. We split the slice, while waiting on the stromboli. The Detroit style slice had an airy crust with crispy, caramelized cheese edges and a daub of sauce on top. During the early lunch rush, our stromboli was forgotten. However, as soon as we inquired the owner/chef got right on it. When it arrived, we split the stromboli stuffed with mozzarella, bacon, ground beef, ham, pepperoni, and sausage and it was amazing. A lot of pizza joints offer calzones, but a good stromboli is more of a unique menu offering. For our extended wait, we were allowed to keep a supreme stromboli the kitchen made in error just prior to firing the meat lovers we ordered. We set the supreme aside for lunch tomorrow. Despite the wait, lunch was delicious and we plan to return.

Malka Shulman

I kept hearing how great this pizza place was, so we finally gave it a try—twice in less than two weeks! 😂 On our first visit, we ordered a plain cheese and a pepperoni pizza. Both were absolutely delicious—authentic New York-style, just as promised. We enjoyed it so much that we came back again not long after. During our second visit, we ordered two pizzas again, but this time the wait felt unusually long. The staff was very apologetic and kindly threw in some garlic rolls to make up for it. Totally worth the wait—the pizzas came out piping hot and just as tasty as the first time. This round, we tried the Margherita and another pepperoni—both excellent. We live within walking distance, and we’re thrilled to have such fantastic pizza so close by. No doubt we’ll be back again soon! Update: We tried the Detroit pizza and- delicious. The crispy cheesy crust was irresistible. We ordered half pepperoni and half cheese. I don't eat pepperoni butthe ones that did both said that it could have used more cheese on top but other than that- we'll be ordering this again!

Michael Johnson

I’ve been hearing awesome things about this place and I finally got the chance to try it. This is quite possibly the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. All of the ingredients tasted delicious and the crust was the PERFECT amount of crispy. Everyone was so friendly and welcoming which made it even more special. I also love that it feels super quaint and tucked away. I can’t wait to come back!

Roli Eats

Pizza by Yandis is tucked inside Carnicería Los Pinos in Sandy Springs, and it’s absolutely worth the stop. I came specifically for their hot honey pepperoni pizza, and it was hands down one of the best I’ve had. The crust is light and crunchy with that perfect bite. The hot honey brings just the right amount of spice without being overwhelming, and the ricotta balances it out with a creamy finish. The pepperoni was cooked to perfection—crispy edges, flavorful, and plenty of it. The staff here is great—friendly and welcoming. While I sat and ate, I noticed how they knew their regulars, asking about their families and catching up. You can tell they care about their customers. Parking is easy since it’s part of the carnicería, and as a bonus, there’s a panadería inside if you want fresh bread or sweets after your pizza. Overall: incredible pizza, friendly service, and definitely a new favorite stop for me when I’m in the area. Highly recommend.

K Speed jr

I saw state Shapiro on Instagram do a review on this place and was working down the street on Glen Lake Parkway and had to try it. I am so impressed. The gentleman in there was so nice to me. Thank you so much. The pizza is so good.