Prima Pizza
Prima Pizza: Savor the tradition, taste the perfection, and experience the warmth of true Italian-American flavors in every bite, right here in Cornwall.
Prima Pizza, at 252 Main St, Cornwall, NY, serves authentic, delicious Italian-American cuisine. Enjoy gourmet pizzas, classic pasta, and hearty heroes made with fresh ingredients and family recipes. A local favorite!
Welcome to Prima Pizza!
Located at 252 Main St, Cornwall, NY 12518, Prima Pizza is your go-to destination for authentic, mouth-watering Italian-American cuisine. For years, we've proudly served the Cornwall community with delicious pizzas, classic pasta dishes, and hearty heroes, all made with the freshest ingredients and a passion for flavor.
Our Menu Highlights:
- Gourmet Pizzas: From classic Margherita to our signature Prima Special, crafted with fresh toppings and a perfect crust.
- Irresistible Appetizers: Garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, and crispy calamari – perfect for sharing or starting your meal.
- Hearty Pasta Dishes: Lasagna, Baked Ziti, Spaghetti with Meatballs, prepared with rich sauces and premium ingredients.
- Fresh Salads & Heroes: Enjoy crisp salads or a satisfying hero sandwich, made to order with quality meats and veggies.
Why Choose Prima Pizza?
- Quality Ingredients: We source the freshest produce, finest cheeses, and premium meats to ensure every bite is exceptional.
- Family Recipes: Our dishes are prepared with time-honored family recipes, bringing authentic flavors to your table.
- Community Favorite: A beloved local spot, known for friendly service and consistent quality.
- Convenient Location: Easily accessible on Main Street, perfect for dine-in, takeout, or delivery to your home.
Whether you're craving a quick slice, a family dinner, or catering for a special event, Prima Pizza delivers unmatched taste and satisfaction. Come visit us or order online and taste the Prima difference today!
Authentic Italian family recipes, freshest ingredients, beloved local reputation, convenient Cornwall Main St location, and consistent, delicious quality every time.
#Pizza
Delivery
During 0hours
The vendor will reach out to confirm the most convenient delivery or pickup option for you.
Payment
Sketchy Pam
Jun 13, 2025
We stopped here for a couple of slices before going to the Stormking Art Center. Thin crust perfection. I had the margarita pizza - an awesome treat. You can get a pizza deliver anywhere by mail too. Go here.
william wortmann
Jun 20, 2025
Cornwall staple of NY style pizza. I used to go here as a kid with my buddies, get a slice and play video games in the back. They took the games out, but it still has the same feel as back then. We enjoyed the white slice and Margherita, garlic knots and calzone. The place is family owned and very friendly/attentive service. They even deliver nationally, my wife has had it delivered to us in Oklahoma multiple times!
THE SHADOW
Jun 22, 2025
Had a wonderful time with wifey and our husky. Ordered a Queen Margherita pie and a few cold ones on hot day. Vincent is a very nice waiter and made sure everything was ok. Thank you, we'll be back.
Drew Bear
Jul 14, 2025
This place has a charming interior. I ate here close to closing time so the pizza wasn’t super fresh. The Sicilian pizza looked really delicious but unfortunately I didn’t get a bite. The pepperoni had a unique flavor at first but became too much as I kept eating it. Overall it’s decent pizza and worth try if you are visiting Cornwall!
Allen Rodriguez
Aug 29, 2025
Prima Pizza on Main Street in Cornwall never disappoints! My regular go-to is the pepperoni with extra cheese, and I love dipping each slice in their marinara—absolutely delicious. The customer service here is top-notch—fast, friendly, and always attentive. The place is constantly buzzing with customers, which tells you it’s the local favorite. Being right in the heart of town, it’s clear this spot has a loyal following, and for good reason. I tried something different tonight with extra cheese, and it looks amazing. Can’t wait to dig in! Highly recommend Prima Pizza to anyone in the area
Stores nearby
More places to order from around 252 Main St · pickup or delivery
Prima Pizza in the Cafes/Restaurants category
Address: Cornwall, 252 Main St
Working hours:
Payment: cash
Delivery with clarification: we will call you back to clarify the most convenient delivery method.
Prima Pizza on the map